What are genes?
Chromosomes contain the recipe for making a living thing. They are found in almost every cell’s nucleus and are made from strands of DNA. Segments of DNA called “genes” are the ingredients, and chromosomes are the structures that contain all the genes. Each gene adds a specific protein to the recipe. Proteins build, regulate and maintain your body. For instance, they build bones, they enable muscles to move, they control digestion, and they keep your heart beating. It is thought that we have about 20,000 genes in our cells that code for all of our traits. Your genes make you what are, they decide virtually everything about you.
Your genes are passed from one generation to the next via your children. We have 46 chromosomes in total; each child receives 23 chromosomes from its mother and 23 from its father. Unfortunately, genes can become damaged – just like a corrupt computer file. If this happens we can suffer illness or even pass this illness to the next generation.
Scientists have discovered that many retinal degenerative conditions are hereditary by studying the DNA from many members of the same family to see if there are any differences. In some cases a gene may not completely control a particular trait, but may partially control it. In this case, a combination of genes and environment may result in illness.
What is gene therapy?
The theory behind gene therapy is to treat the disease by repairing the abnormal gene. This is achieved by replacing the disease causing faulty gene with a “normal” copy into an individual’s cells. The most successful method to deliver the gene to the cells is by using a virus that has been genetically modified to carry human DNA. The eye has proved to be an ideal organ for gene therapy as it is well protected from the body’s immune response, and these early successes will pave the way in the near future for treatments for both inherited and non-inherited forms of blindness.
In November 2012 a milestone was reached when Glybera®, which is for the treatment of a rare metabolic disorder known as lipoprotein lipase deficiency (LPLD), became the first gene therapy to be granted regulatory approval in Europe. Although this is not directly related to retinal research, it represents a huge step towards the development of registered and approved retinal gene therapies.
What conditions can benefit from gene therapy?
Any condition where the faulty gene that is responsible for the disorder is known has the potential to benefit from gene therapy. Examples are forms of retinitis pigmentosa and Leber congential amaurosis. Other illnesses that are thought to be partially affected by genes and partially by our environment (e.g. lifestyle, exposure to sunlight) like age-related macular degeneration may also benefit from such a therapy in the future.
Blindness is only one disease which researchers are hoping gene therapy will cure. Others include severe combined immunodeficiency, haemophilia, Parkinson’s disease, cancer and even HIV.
Gene Therapy Projects Supported by Fighting Blindness
Fighting Blindness realises the potential of gene therapy for the treatment of retinal degenerations and has a strong commitment to funding research in this area. Examples of some recently funded research projects are:
2012: Exploration of AAV-delivered gene therapies for Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) – Professor Jane Farrar, Trinity College, Dublin. Read point 1 below for further explanation.
2011: Exploration of the candidacy of RPE65 in the etiology of adRP with choroidal involvement. – Prof Pete Humphries, Trinity College Dublin. Read point 2 below for further explanation.
2008: Development of gene and cell therapies for the treatment of retinal degeneration – Prof Robin Ali, Moorfields Hospital, London. Read point 3 below for further explanation.
2008: Clinical trials of gene therapy for retinitis pigmentosa – Prof Jane Farrar, Genable & Trinity College, Dublin.
2007: Optimal expansion and differentiation into photoreceptors of adult retinal stem cells from porcine pigmented ciliary epithelium – Dr Tiziana Cogliati, Queens University Belfast.
2006: On the molecular pathology of retinal degeneration caused by mutations within the IMPDH1 gene – Prof Pete Humphries, Trinity College Dublin.
1. Fighting Blindness continues to support gene therapy for Leber Hereditary Optic Neuropathy (LHON).
We are delighted to announce that Fighting Blindness will continue to support Irish research regarding the development of gene therapy for Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON). Professor Jane Farrar and Dr. Naomi Chadderton of Trinity College, Dublin were recently successful in their application for funding through the joint funding scheme established by the Medical Research Charities Group (MRCG), which sees the Health Research Board match the funding invested into research by medical research charities in Ireland. Through this scheme, Fighting Blindness will directly invest €150,000 over the next three years towards this research and this will be matched by the Health Research Board.
Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) is a maternally inherited disorder affecting the mitochondrial DNA. Children inherit their mitochondrial DNA only from their mother, unlike nuclear DNA which comes from the mother and father. A woman carrying a LHON mutation will pass it to all of her children; men with the LHON gene never pass it to their children. Individuals with LHON experience fast, sudden, painless loss of vision in both eyes in their late teens or early 20s. Males are more commonly affected than females. The mitochondria are often referred to as the “powerhouses of the cell” because the mitochondria take in glucose and produce energy. In LHON, a mutation in the mitochondrial DNA leads to a loss of energy transfer to the optic nerve and a degeneration of the cells, resulting in loss of vision.
This investment will enable the continuation of the development of viral technology that will deliver a gene that provides energy back to the eye cells, preventing those cells from dying. We are extremely pleased that the scientific excellence of this project and urgent clinical necessity for the development of treatments for this disorder has been recognised by the Health Research Board and we are glad to be able to support this important project over the next three years.
2. Exploration of the candidacy of RPE65 in the etiology of adRP with choroidal involvement
Prof Pete Humphries, Ocular Genetics Unit in Trinity College Dublin
Prof Humphries and his team have identified two families from Ireland who have autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa. Autosomal dominant is one of several ways that a disorder can be passed down through families. If a disorder is autosomal dominant, it means that you only need to get the abnormal gene from one parent in order for you to inherit the disease. In the families in this study, members have a mutation on the RPE65 gene.
Up until this point, this particular gene has been associated with more rare conditions, so it is very interesting to discover that the mutation may be more common than previously suspected. There is evidence to show that it could cause up to 20% of cases with another condition called choroideremia.
Prof Humphries and his lab plan to use cultured cell lines to further their work. Cultured cells are cells of a single type (human, animal or plant) that have been adapted to grow continuously in a lab so that they can be used in research. The team will be closely examining mutant proteins in these cells as well as screening for further mutations in other cases of RP with choroidal involvement.
Prof Humphries is hopeful that these studies may reveal a new disease mechanism associated with RP and may also bear relevance to the design of future therapy opportunities. Fighting Blindness is glad to be able to support this important project as we learn more about the genetics of retinal degeneration’s in Irish families and, importantly, progress towards the development of treatments.
3. Revolutionary gene therapy helps restore young man’s sight
Fighting Blindness helped fund the world’s first clinical trial to test a revolutionary gene therapy treatment which improved a young man’s sight.
Professor Robin Ali pioneered the first ever successful trial of gene therapy for a form of blindness called Leber’s Congenital Amaurosis.
The research conducted by Professor Robin Ali at University College London and Moorfields Eye Hospital in London brings hope to millions affected by eye diseases as a result of revolutionary gene therapy treatment.
Prof Ali treated a patient who has a rare genetic eye disease called Leber’s Congenital Amaurosis (LCA). Steven Howarth, then 18, from Bolton, England, (pictured centre above with Prof Robin Ali, right, and Prof Michael Comer, left, Fighting Blindness Head of Research) had been left with extremely poor vision and completely unable to see in the dark.
Following the treatment, his sight improved sufficiently to be able to navigate a ‘maze’ in conditions similar to street lighting at night.
Prof Ali managed to replace the faulty ‘RPE65’ gene causing the condition with a normal gene. The therapy was delivered in a harmless virus or ‘vector’ which was injected into the back of the eye and spread to the cells.
As well as part-funding the UCL project, Fighting Blindness funds a similar project at Trinity College Dublin which is focused on developing a similar therapy but for a different type of gene, which causes Retinitis Pigmentosa – a condition leading to tunnel vision.
Professor Jane Farrar, of the Trinity College project, said: “This is great news. It shows that in principle gene-based medicines for the eye provide some hope for patients with many different forms of genetic eye disease”.
Commenting on the findings, Professor Ali said: “Showing for the first time that gene therapy can work in patients with eye disease is a very significant milestone. This trial establishes proof of principle of gene therapy for inherited retinal disease and paves the way for the development of gene therapy approaches for a broad range of eye disorders.
“These results give us great confidence that this technique is safe and can bring real benefit to patients with impaired vision. While we’re very excited about the improvement in Steven’s vision, it’s important to emphasise that gene therapy is still an experimental treatment not yet generally available to patients. The technique will be tested in other patients with LCA and we also hope to begin trials for other forms of retinal disease in the future.”
The researchers believe the operation’s success for Steven could be because his disease had not progressed to the same extent as the other two patients in the trial
Global Gene Therapy Research
LCA2 Clinical Trial Story
One particular gene therapy story is a remarkable example about how a long research road has come to a clinical fruition. It has resulted in an incredible breakthrough offering hope to children and young adults who are afflicted by a rare and devastating form of Leber Congenital Amaurosis (LCA).
In 1993, a group in the United States identified the gene RPE65 as being a causative gene for LCA. This gene was the second gene identified to be linked with LCA, so this form of the disease is known as LCA2. After identification of the gene, the first thing the researchers set out to do was to create mice with a deleted RPE65 gene in order to study what was the exact function of RPE65. After proving that it was indeed a faulty RPE65 gene that caused the rapid loss of vision in the mice, they set about investigating gene therapy as a method to repair the defective piece of DNA. They employed an adenovirus, a harmless virus to package the RPE65 gene and transmit it to the mice and in doing so they successfully delivered the gene to the retina of the mice.
Mice models are excellent for studying a disease, but they have limitations for developing clinically relevant therapies. The fledgling therapy next needed to be tested in an animal that have eyes more similar to the human. Interestingly, a French breed of sheepdog was identified to be predisposed to develop a form of blindness extremely similar to LCA2. Briard dogs are often born blind and the researchers discovered that their blindness was caused by a defect in the RPE65 gene. The first group of dogs were treated in 2001 and the results were remarkable. These dogs are intelligent sheepdogs and they love performing tasks and the treated dogs were able to navigate mazes without any problems. One of the dogs named Lancelot pictured below became a sensation when he visited the United States Congress and shook hands with the senators. Lancelot still retains good vision 11 years after initial treatment.
The extensive testing of RPE65 gene therapy in mice, rats and dogs paved the way for the first human clinical trial to take place in 2008. Fighting Blindness’s chief scientific officer, Professor Robin Ali led the team in a small trial involving young adults which was partially funded by Fighting Blindness. This initial trial proved that the procedure was safe, and a number of the participants saw an improvement in their sight. Since then, the number of LCA2 trials worldwide has grown and the evidence from these multiple, independent trials is that the procedure is extremely safe. Most of these recent trials are now recruiting children as young as five years old, as the focus is now on early treatment.
LCA2 may be a rare disorder, but many lessons have been learned. The method of gene delivery has been shown to be safe and the treatment has demonstrated good efficacy. This has allowed many of the regulatory hurdles to be cleared that stand in the way of licencing a new therapy. The LCA2 trials stand as a milestone in gene therapy retinal research and will allow for the expansion of the investigation of gene therapy for some of the other more common inherited degenerations.
Selected Other Gene Therapy Clinical Trials
Usher Syndrome Type 1B: Usher Syndrome Type 1B is caused by mutations in the Myosin VIIA gene. Viral delivery of the Myosin VIIA gene in pre-clinical mouse models indicated improvement in visual function and a human clinical trial to determine efficacy and safety began recruiting patients early in 2012 in Portland, Oregon, USA. Three patients have been treated so far with no adverse effects six months after treatment.
Choroideremia: Choroideremia is characterised by a deletion of the REP1 gene. Professor Robert McLaren of the Oxford Eye Hospital is currently conducting a phase I/II trial and recruiting patients in four sites in the UK.
Wet AMD: A gene therapy clinical trial has begun that delivers anti-angiongenic genes (genes that block the formation of abnormal blood vessels) to the retina. This trial is called the RetinoStat clinical trial and a total of nine patients have been treated thus far with no adverse events.
Stargardt Disease: It is now 12 months into the StarGen clinical trial; those receiving the lowest dose after 12 months have experienced no adverse events. Higher doses are planned for the next patients to be recruited.
Links to studies mentioned in article:
(Please note: Fighting Blindness cannot be held responsible for information from other websites)
Glybera Approval: First gene therapy to be granted regulatory approval in Europe
Robin Ali LCA2 gene therapy trial: First gene therapy trial in the world for blindness
Usher Syndrome Clinical Trial: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01505062?term=usher&rank=3
Stargardt Disease: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01367444?term=stargen&rank=2